Jamaal Bowman, a progressive incumbent within the US Home of Representatives, misplaced his main election to the extra centrist Democrat candidate George Latimer, the latter of whom’s marketing campaign was flooded with hundreds of thousands of {dollars} from the pro-Israel foyer Aipac.
Bowman’s loss poses an enormous setback for “the Squad”, the small cadre of progressive lawmakers that first got here to Congress in 2018.
Nevertheless, the loss can be indicative of a tenure in workplace that lacked constant political positions and a capability to straddle the road between sustaining the help of the bigger progressive motion, the grassroots motion in help of Palestine, and his constituency, a lot of which exists outdoors the Bronx and within the majority white county of Westchester.
A lot of this may very well be seen in the truth that Bowman took a number of political stances, solely to rapidly stroll them again, significantly on the problem of Palestine and Israel’s conflict on Gaza.
The election outcomes on Tuesday for New York’s sixteenth congressional district have been clear early into the evening. Latimer, who beforehand served because the county govt for Westchester, simply defeated Bowman by 17 factors.
Keep knowledgeable with MEE’s newsletters
Signal as much as get the newest alerts, insights and evaluation,
beginning with Turkey Unpacked
The American-Israel Public Affairs Committee (Aipac) spent a complete of $14m within the race in help of Bowman, and with a complete of round $23m spent on the race from all sides, the first election was the costliest within the historical past of the Home of Representatives.
Based on Politico, Bowman attacked Aipac for coming into the election, saying the pro-Israel foyer helped to “brainwash” voters.
The protection of the race had been stuffed with the politician’s stance on Israel and its conflict on Gaza, with Bowman repeatedly referring to Latimer as being purchased out by Aipac.
Flipping on Palestine
Bowman entered the nationwide political scene in 2020 when he defeated the incumbent candidate Eliot Engel, one of the distinguished pro-Israel voices in Congress and an influential politician that had beforehand chaired the Home International Affairs Committee.
His election to Congress was seen as an enormous victory for the progressive motion, and he was added to a rising listing of “Squad” members that included Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib, amongst others.
A protest in opposition to Jamaal Bowman revealed the bounds of progressive help for Palestine
Learn Extra »
Earlier than coming into workplace, he spoke publicly in an interview with Jacobin about his criticisms of US navy help to Israel.
However simply months into his tenure, rifts started to emerge between him and different progressives. In September 2021, Bowman voted in favour of funding Israel’s Iron Dome missile system, a vote that got here simply after Israel’s 2021 conflict on Gaza. He was the only member of the Squad to take action.
Then in November 2021, Bowman travelled to Israel and met with then-Israeli Prime Minister Naftali Bennett in a visit sponsored by the liberal Zionist organisation J Road.
That journey violated the ideas of the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), of which Bowman was a member. Bowman, like different progressives, publicly stated he doesn’t help the Palestinian-led Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) motion targetting Israel’s occupation of Palestine.
The DSA in the end voted to not expel Bowman however added that it will not endorse Bowman within the 2022 election. Nevertheless, the choice triggered inner outrage inside the organisation and the bigger progressive motion, and would have ripple results over the subsequent few years.
Criticising Israel, then apologising
Since Israel’s conflict on Gaza started in October, Bowman has criticised the Israeli navy for its actions within the besieged enclave.
He has accused Israel of committing genocide in Gaza, and was an early proponent of a ceasefire in Gaza.
However the congressman took a number of steps that noticed him anger the pro-Palestine group, whereas additionally upsetting his pro-Israel Jewish constituents.
In November, Bowman referred to the stories that Hamas used rape as a weapon of conflict as Israeli propaganda — a number of claims of rape through the 7 October assaults have been denied and debunked, together with one during which an Israeli kibbutz spokesperson denied the allegations of rape in a New York Occasions article.
After receiving assaults for his feedback, he walked them again and apologised, saying: “I apologise for my feedback and now we’re persevering with to do the work to struggle sexual violence and home violence in all its kinds.”
In January, Bowman reportedly stated that he was “a bit starstruck” when he met Norman Finkelstein, the creator of many books on Israel and Palestine and a foremost critic of Israel’s therapy of Palestinians.
![](https://www.middleeasteye.net/sites/default/files/styles/read_more/public/images-story/jamaal%20bowman%20afp.jpeg.webp?itok=0cncQc46)
Professional-Israel lobbying group Aipac launches advert marketing campaign in opposition to Jamaal Bowman
Learn Extra »
Nevertheless, Bowman then confronted a number of assaults over his feedback, which denigrated Finkelstein for laying a part of the blame for the 7 October assaults on Israel for its longstanding therapy of Palestinians and siege on Gaza.
Once more, the politician rapidly apologised, and went on to discuss with Finkelstein’s feedback as “reprehensible” and stated he condemned them.
A number of weeks in the past, Bowman, together with different progressive lawmakers together with Ocasio-Cortez, denigrated a rally held by the Palestinian organisation Inside Our Lifetime and labelled it antisemitic.
That rally, which was being held to mourn for the greater than 200 Palestinians massacred in an Israeli hostage operation in central Gaza, moved to confront the Nova exhibition, which was created to memorialise the people killed at a music pageant held close to Gaza on the day of the 7 October assaults.
The exhibition holds notes calling for the annihilation of the Palestinian folks in Gaza.
Just a few days earlier than the first election between Bowman and Latimer, Bowman held a rally within the Bronx alongside Ocasio-Cortez and Senator Bernie Sanders in an try to lift last-minute help for the marketing campaign, which was already behind within the polls.
In response, Inside Our Lifetime held a protest in opposition to the three politicians, with a number of calls for, specifically calling on them to rescind their endorsement of President Joe Biden and to cease equating anti-Zionism with antisemitism.
The rally obtained the help of a number of grassroots organisations together with the Palestinian Youth Motion, and was endorsed by the Gaza solidarity encampments at a number of universities in New York.
Nevertheless, progressive political organisers together with a number of DSA members attacked the rally, saying it was aiding Aipac and the pro-Israel foyer in opposition to Bowman.
In the end, Bowman’s marketing campaign tried to achieve the help of the bigger pro-Palestine motion that has taken over the streets of the US, whereas additionally attempting to curry favour with the pro-Israel members of his personal constituency.